Year Location Winner Runner-up
2010 Hancock Boomtown Saints Blame the Dog
2011 Calumet Boomtown Saints Blame the Dog
2012 Calumet Appleton Assassins Cupola Bandits
2013 Calumet Boomtown Saints Appleton Assassins
2014 Calumet Boomtown Saints Appleton Assassins
2015 Calumet Boomtown Saints Appleton Assassins
2016 Calumet Expert Villagers Boomtown Saints
2017 Calumet Appleton Assassins Carmelita’s
2018 Calumet Appleton Assassins Boomtown Saints